by
Marjorie Simon [Metalsmith Magazine - Summer 2004]
"When any useful thing is designed the shape of it is in no way imposed on
the designer, or determined by any influence outside him .... All the
works of man look as they do from his choice, and not from necessity."'
"Being next to a big old tree has always been one of my favorite places."
Tom Muir
Universal Joint Bracelet,
2003
sterling silver, nickel, stainless steel
3 1/8 x 2 5/8 x 1"
Photo: Tim Thayer
First impressions can be
misleading. Take Tom Muir, for instance. In person, he seems like a mischievous
younger brother with an easy-going southern drawl. His affable persona masks a
tenderness and grace that he expresses in refined and often witty holloware.
Muir's work hovers between craft and design, science and nature. To understand
it, look to the forest and the trees- the forest for its interrelatedness and
the ecosystems that inhabit the physical space, and the trees for their
symmetry, their geometry, and their spirituality.
Muir has always felt strongly
about trees. As a boy he was comforted by a "best friend tree." Now he shepherds
24 acres of forestland in the high grasslands of Ohio , where a cold dry climate
and fertile glacial soils support forests of hardwood trees. The dominant
ecosystems that influence his life and work are anchored by an unusually large
variety of indigenous species, some of which are estimated to be hundreds of
years old.
The Definition of is (espresso server)
2000
sterling silver, aluminum, acetal 11 1/4 x 2 3/4 x 5"
Photo: Tim Thayer
Born in 1956, Muir grew up in
suburban Atlanta , hence the long vowels and soft speech. His early childhood
was spent in that contradictory period of American history known as the 1950s,
and he was a teenager (luring the Vietnam era. But his real roots are found in a
value system of craftsmanship and utility; from his father he absorbed a work
ethic in which one never cuts corners.
Though he wasn't aware of it
during his childhood, Muir's family tree was populated with craftsmen and
metalworkers, including two blacksmiths, jewelers, a boat builder, and a
glassblower. Encouraged from an early age to express his creativity, Muir
studied drafting in high school and then drawing at Georgia State University .
His first college art class was team-taught by Richard Mafong and the late Jem
Freyaldenhoven. In graduate school at Indiana University he studied with Randy
Long and Leslie Leupp. The influence of Leupp's airy and linear sculpture and
objects is most evident in Muir's work of the 1980s. What attracted him to
making jewelry were things that had always interested him, specifically
technique, process, challenge. Muir thought learning metalsmithing would he like
studying a difficult musical instrument: if he could do that, he could do
anything.
Structure, nature, and balance
underlie Muir's engineering and are represented aesthetically by his use of
mirroring and interrelated forms. He looks for the structural or transitional
elements in the natural arrangement of things, and the objects he makes reveal
that combination of man-made and natural forms. He considers the totality: the
Woods, soil types, the geometry of nature. What is the temperature of the water?
Is it running water or still?
Domestic objects such as tea
infusers and tea servers are based on the harmonious symbiosis of air ecosystem.
What distinguishes Muir's work from other nature-based designs is its elegant
subtext. A coffee pot in the shape of a tree wouldn't be nearly as interesting
as the organic, often sexualized androgynous globes that bulge from Muir's
containers. The perfect forms of Muir's holloware may seem removed from random
patterns of leaves and branches, but think of the moment in Mondrian's Visual
development when the tree fractured into lines, and you have an idea of Muir's
preoccupation with the perfect reflection: the moment when reality and
reflection or illusion come together. He considers vertical symmetry, the
dialogue between object and image, the nature of boundaries and inversion, and
what it means to reflect." Muir's latest containers, both the tire tea infusers
and the larger teapots, exemplify these recurring themes. They comment on the
traditions of making as well as changing social mores.
Silver has been a part of
American domestic ritual and tradition since the eighteenth and nineteenth
centuries, when bourgeois families used coffee and tea services, serving
utensils, and other silver domestic objects in imitation of their English
Counterparts. A robust American silver design and manufacturing industry gross
a, people of means were no longer satisfied to live with homemade utensils and
furnishings, and fine craftsmen became a part of the social-culturaleconomic
nexus. The wealthy had sterling silver gravy hosts, porringers, and crumb trays,
and the middle classes had silverplated items of similar design. Even the big
silver designers such as Gorham and Tiffany created whimsical and ornate
holloware and utensils according to the prevailing design motifs of the time.
Commercially available modernist pitchers from the 1930s seem close cousins of
Muir's vessels.
Tazza, 1992
copper, bronze, brass, sterling silver, copper place, steel
20 x 10 x10 "
Photo: Rod Wheless
Tea Infuser, 1993
sterling silver
6 1/4 x 1 1/2 x 1 1/2"
Photo: Tim Thayer
This history forms the deep
background of Muir's vessels. Muir's design motifs have ranged from medieval
mace to nurturing hand to natureinspired spirals and leaves. He commemorates the
tradition that produced them, recalling them as commonplace objects that are
recognized even if they're no longer in everyday use, He uses the ideal of an
elegant silver coffee server to create a bawdy, sexually ambiguous vessel in
The Definition of Is (2000), linking an
old-fashioned form with one of America's most embarrassing moments, the
Clinton-Lewinsky debacle. Its sexualized contours hint at escapades lurking in
the best of homes. More than one of Muir's vessels intimates the moment of
sexual differentiation, or androgyny. In choosing a provocative title, Muir
threatens to undermine the seriousness of his intent. Viewers may fix on the
deception, either than, as Muir intends, the immanent. By this he means "the
moment when sexual principles come into the universe and there is an awareness
of being that is erotic." In this case the title, though amusing, is a little
misleading.
Tea infusers are popular
domestic objects for silversmiths. Like the black Bakelite telephone, they are
easily recognizable, and their obvious function provides a little structure
around which much experimentation can take place. They're not so serious that
they cannot support a playful treatment and they are a favorite of students
everywhere. Muir has made many of them, often paired with larger teapots,
including the Changing Hand (2002) version and the silver Watercraft (2003)
infuser with copper Watercourse (2003) teapot.
Watercourse (teapot)
2003
copper, brass aluminum 12 1/2 x 4 x 7 1/4"
Photo: Tim Thayer
Changing Hand (teapot),
2002
copper brass 12 x 2 1/2 x 7"
Photo: Tim Thayer
The tea infuser gives Muir a
chance to work in a smaller, though no less challenging, format, and to comment
on the value of utility and the interrelationship of all things. In 1991, he
used sterling silver, giving his designs a coolformalism. A decade later, the
Changing Hand Tea Infuser (followed by the Changing Hand Tea Pot in 2002) warms
with the addition of gold and encoded nature references. An oak leaf on the palm
side signifies strength, masculinity, and tenacity and the transformational
nature of seed into mature tree, a common metaphor for growth (acorns into
mighty oaks). It also refers to the practice of finding bits of history in
fields, old man-made objects that become part of the natural landscape. The
perforated side where the tea drains out contains the rings of the tree that
reveal its age. In the Watercraft tea infuser, some holes appear as a shadow
pattern beneath the leaf and others are on the ends of the fingers and thumb. By
making them flattened ovals rather than cylinders, the vessels have two distinct
sides with two related images-and an implied relationship between them.
In the mid-1980s, Muir openly
explored the relationship of man and machine in works that were more
mechanistic. Although he is still interested in machines, Muir's work now is
more humanistic and relational, as shown in Watercraft and Watercourse. His
skill and fascination with working parts leads him to make a springloaded door
on the tea infusers: turn the thumb to open the chamber and fill with tea. As
each piece is being formulated in his mind, Muir considers what it means and
what he wants to convey, that is, the "essence" of the object, the vesselness of
it. His skillful drawings and paper models precede the complex assembly of all
kinds of domestic and personal objects, including eyeglasses, cups, salt and
pepper shakers, and even a Hanukkiah, the nine-cupped candelabrum used during
the Jewish festival of Hanukkah.
Espresso Server, 1991
sterling silver, nickel, oxidized aluminum
10 1/2 x 5 1/2 x 3 1/4"
White House Collection of American Crafts
Photo: Tom Muir
Muir's vessels have continued to
swoop and dive into the 1990s and beyond, some like Komelia Okim's gliding
figures, others like Leupp's pipes and lamps. They recall the design aesthetic
of the mid-1950s-60s known as Populuxe. The design of Populuxe objects promised
fun and luxury, not a severe functionalism -appearance was more important than
utility, It was anti-arts-and-crafts, and characterized by a desire to eschew
the historic, he traditional, and the ethnic, and to embrace the fantasy of the
new. The most salient example of this aesthetic is, of course, automobile design
and the romance of jet engine-inspired fins. Growing up in the car culture of
the south certainly contributed to Muir's aesthetic, but he was also influenced
by domestic objects of the time such as his mother's aluminum egg cooker. He
remembers it resembling "a space ship from cheap 1950s sci-fi movies,' and that
shape can be found in more than one vessel, including an espresso server (1991)
in the White House Collection.
Muir's 1994 entry in "Design
Visions International: Directions in Class, American Jewellery and Metalwork ,
Australia " is illustrative. In the Tazza
(dish), a twisted Nine topped with a spiky caterpillar emerges from a satellite
dish that is itself embellished A with a tuning fork, as if Jack's beanstalk
culminated in an insect from outer space. At the time, Muir was teaching at the
Center for creative Studies in Detroit (now the College for Creative Studies),
which gave commentators Sarah Bodine and Michael Dunas reason to call Muir "a
boulevardier from Detroit" and to frame his choice of holloware in terms of the
many possibilities inherent in the larger format.
It is in these larger objects
that "one can see the traditional enthusiasm Americans have for the highly
individualistic, the iconoclastic, and vernacular and the pastiche that form
then- own language of independence from classic European tradition.... Muir's
design sensibilities for elegant functional pitchers and Cal borders on the
flare of an auto body customiser." Of course Muir was hardly the first designer
to incorporate the romance of speed. In 1925, silversmith Johannes Steltman was
inspired to by a racecar to create a tea service of enamel, silver, and
semi-precious stones (although in truth it looks more like a fish And as
recently as 1984 Austrian Hans Hollein designed a tea service for Alessi called
Aircraft Carrier.
Sarah Bodine brought the maker
back into the discussion of design, when she posed the provocative question of
"whether holloware's sculptural possibilities derive from the inside or the
outside of the piece, whether the creative process pushes the skin outwards or
whether the skin is raised to envelop and Calm the turbulent atmosphere of its
interior space. Where does the true character of holloware lie?" No one raises,
sinks, folds, or encloses a vessel without taking on the history of holding Muir
is always aware of working back and forth, inside and out. His affection for
Populuxe expression is sustained by a maker's concern for meaning. Makers of
holloware take on the issue of containment from the outset, as Lisa Gralnick
pointed out in her excellent essay in the 2001 Exhibition in Print.' The vessel
is both container and contained, with the interior space as important as
exterior. In contrast to, say, Hat-Ian Butt's incense burners, which seem to
personify serenity, Muir's undulating, often asymmetrical forms seem to just
barely contain some perverse imp, or energy, waiting to jump out.
Tom Muir's silver containers
connect man and nature. Rather than separate natural forms from machined ones,
Muir reminds us of the unity that link, biology to physics, the sympathy of hi
between the atom and the cosmos, the cell and the organism. Biology is both the
impetus mad the recipient of engineering. Organisms are a collection of pumps,
valves, filters, pipes, hinges and ball joints. Universal joint Bracelet, made
in 2003, seems more closely related to the internal structure of a limb or wing
than to a statement about adornment for its external form. Gleaming silver
articulates its complex movement and flexion, unlike the actual wrist whose
connections will wear out in a few thousand repetitive motions. Today, bionic
physiology covers a titanium hill joint with literal skin. An integral hinge is
invisible on the exterior ,if a coffee per or tea infuser. Neither will move
smoothly without careful engineering. Muir references nature in an oblique way,
glancing off the literal, so it's unclear whether that bulge is a breast or an
engine cowling. Following the model of the tree whose hidden roots are equal in
size to the visible branches, Muir's deep knowledge of nature supports his
visible mechanics. When he chooses, he can make an anatomically correct white
oak leaf, or just suggest leafness with a more generic form.
"The observations and
discoveries I make [in the woods] every day are important in my work. I try to
view the bigger picture along with some of the smaller details that usually go
unnoticed." To facilitate his meditations, Muir cuts trails so he can visit the
"largest, most impressive trees."' One chinkapin oak spreads its full majestic
crown because there are no neighboring trees to compete for sell, water, or sun.
A tree with a four-foot diameter trunk carries a lot of history within its
cells. The details Muir includes in his vessels also contain a history, whether
personal, such as the oak leaf in Changing Hand Tea Infuser, or social, as in
the many coffee and tea servers, or even political, as in The Definition of Is.
By adopting the hand as his most recent metaphor, Muir brings human agency and
reference to craftsmanship back to the fore. The hand raised in greeting seems
to arrest or caution the viewer as well.
Industrial designer David Pye
once questioned functionalism by taking apart the questions about what a thing
"does," demonstrating the folly of imagining that there can be only one answer.
Muir's working philosophy is to challenge form in the context of utility. He
looks at "use" or function and tries to see how many ways it can be imagined. It
is often noted that art looks backward and forward at the same time. ? Tom
Muir's trajectory from the "boulevardier of Detroit " to snails and tree rings
moves with the times, but looks over its shoulder all the same.
Marjorie Simon is a metalsmith and writer based in New Jersey.